Thredup vs Poshmark: Complete Seller Comparison & Tips for 2025

Whether you're just clearing out your wardrobe or trying to make serious money, platforms like Poshmark and thredUP make it easier than ever to sell online. However, for sellers, choosing the right platform can significantly impact their profits, time, and overall selling experience.

While both Poshmark and ThredUp facilitate secondhand clothing transactions, their approaches, target markets, and user experiences differ significantly. In this article, we'll break down the key differences between ThredUp and Poshmark, share expert tips for success on each, and help you decide which is best for your resale goals. Read on for a complete comparison in our ThredUp vs Poshmark breakdown.

Part 1. What Is ThredUp? Overview for Sellers

ThredUp is an online consignment store that makes it easy to buy and sell preloved clothing. It focused on making secondhand clothing shopping and selling easy and eco-friendly. The standout feature of this tool is that the ThredUp team handles the entire selling process for you - simply pack up your clothes and send them in. ThredUp handles photographing, listing, pricing, and shipping, so you can relax and wait for your payout.

While comparing Poshmark vs ThredUp, ThredUp's proprietary technology can find over 100K unique items for everyday use. This platform also offers users a style chat feature, allowing them to describe their style with a prompt and receive personalized clothing options.

Part 2. What Is Poshmark? Seller Guide

Poshmark is an online reselling marketplace best known for new and secondhand fashion. With over 80 million community members across the United States and Canada, Poshmark is a leading social e-commerce marketplace for new and secondhand fashion. Unlike ThredUp, Poshmark gives sellers full control over their listings, pricing, and communication with buyers, making it ideal for hands-on sellers.

To sell on Poshmark, simply create an account, upload multiple photos of your item, write a description, and set your price. Once a sale is made, Poshmark sends you a prepaid shipping label. You then package the item and drop it off for shipping.

Part 3. Thredup vs Poshmark: Key Differences for Sellers

ThredUp or Poshmark are both leading e-commerce platforms for selling second-hand clothing. But which one is better for you as a seller? To help you decide, below we have mentioned the key differences between the two platforms so you can choose the one that best fits your selling style and goals.

1. Listing Process and Ease of Use

• ThredUp: ThredUp offers a completely hands-off approach. Sellers simply send in their clothes using a Clean Out Kit or prepaid label, and ThredUp handles everything.
• Poshmark: Poshmark requires sellers to take photos, write descriptions, and manage their listings.

2. Fees, Commission, and Payout Speed

• ThredUp: Its commission structure varies by item value, with payouts ranging from 5% to 80%. Payouts can take weeks, depending on processing times and when an item sells.
• Poshmark: Poshmark takes a flat fee of $2.95 for sales under $15 and 20% for sales above $15. Payouts are faster, released once the buyer receives and accepts the order.

3. Shipping Responsibilities and Customer Support

• ThredUp: With ThredUp, sellers have no shipping responsibilities; it takes care of packing and shipping to buyers. Customer Support of ThredUp is very cooperative.
• Poshmark: It requires sellers to package and ship sold items using the platform's prepaid label.

Part 4. Poshmark or Thredup: Which Platform Fits Your Selling Style?

Choosing between Poshmark and ThredUp for selling depends on your priorities, time availability, and selling volume. Poshmark suits sellers who enjoy the social aspects of fashion, have time to manage listings and customer relationships. On the other hand, ThredUp is ideal if you prefer a hand-off approach with minimal time investment.

Further, ThredUp focuses on everyday women's and kids' fashion, favoring well-known mid-range brands in good condition. Poshmark supports a wider range of categories, including luxury items, men's fashion, beauty products, and home goods.

Thredup vs Poshmark: Tip to Choose the Best Platform for Your Needs

• If you have a busy schedule and prefer not to manage sales yourself, then we recommend that you choose ThredUp.
• Choose Poshmark if you're willing to invest time, want to build a brand or side business, and have unique or trendy items.

Part 5. [Bonus Tip] Boost Your Listings with HitPaw FotorPea AI Product Image Tool

It doesn't matter if you choose Poshmark or ThredUp; high-quality product images are essential for driving sales on both platforms. HitPaw FotorPea is one of the best AI Image Enhancers available on the internet, allowing users to enhance product images to a higher quality with the help of AI. This powerful tool uses advanced AI technology to automatically sharpen, brighten, and upscale your product photos in seconds. Whether you're working with old smartphone images or need to remove background distractions, FotorPea can help your listings look professional and polished - no photo editing skill required.

Key Features of HitPaw FotorPea

• AI Background Replacement: HitPaw FotorPea automatically removes messy backgrounds and replaces them with a clean and professional background. Perfect for marketplaces like ThredUp, Poshmark, Amazon, and Shopify.
• Enhance Product Images: With the help of this tool, sellers can easily enhance their product images, making low-quality product photos look sharp and professional.
• Batch Processing: This feature allows users to generate multiple product images at once, saving time and effort.
• Easy to Use Interface: The standout feature of this tool is that it offers an intuitive interface, allowing beginners to enhance product images without professional help.

Step-by-Step Guide to Create AI Product Image for Thredup & Poshmark

If you want to create AI product images for ThredUp and Poshmark, HitPaw FotorPea is one of the best tools to try. Here is how to do it:

• Visit the HitPaw FotorPea official site and click on the "Download" button to get the latest version of the software. Install it on your PC. Launch it and choose "AI Product Image" from Toolbox.
• Next, click on the "+" sign to upload your product photo for background generation. Users can upload images in multiple formats, including PNG and JPG.
• Next, select the recommend background or upload reference picture to generate the background of your product photo. Click on "Generate" to begin the process.
• After a few seconds later your product image with desired background will be ready. Preview the results and click "Download" to export the image in popular formats.

Conclusion

This ThredUp vs Poshmark guide covers everything you need to know to compare both platforms and choose the one that best suits your selling needs. ThredUp and Poshmark are both eco-friendly ways to refresh your closet - the best option just comes down to your preferences.

Additionally, we've introduced you to an image enhancer, HitPaw FotorPea - a powerful tool that lets users effortlessly improve the quality of their product photos.